welcome to creating calm chaos. please make yourself at home

Homemade Marshmallows

Make soft, fluffy homemade vanilla marshmallows with easy step-by-step instructions, delicious variations and tips for gifting and hot chocolate.

11/11/20262 min read

A plate of homemade fluffy white marshmallows served with hot chocolate for a cozy winter treat.
A plate of homemade fluffy white marshmallows served with hot chocolate for a cozy winter treat.

Homemade Marshmallows

Soft, Fluffy and Nothing Like the Shop Kind

If you've only ever had marshmallows from a bag, a homemade one is a bit of a revelation. It's soft, springy and tastes properly of vanilla, and it melts into a mug of hot chocolate like a little cloud. A jar of them, tied up with ribbon, is one of those gifts people say "you made these?" about, and then eat far too quickly.

They look like a fancy kitchen project, but they're really just a sugar syrup, some gelatine and a lot of whisking by machine. The one thing you need is a candy thermometer and an electric mixer, and the one thing you need to respect is the hot syrup. Get everything ready first, move calmly, and you'll have a tray of fluff by bedtime that sets overnight while you sleep.

Suits both a summer and a winter Christmas. In summer they're lovely with berries and ice cream, in winter they belong in hot chocolate.

Homemade marshmallows troubleshooting guide chart outlining problems and fixes for soft, tough, or sticky candies.
Homemade marshmallows troubleshooting guide chart outlining problems and fixes for soft, tough, or sticky candies.

Making It With the Kids/Grandkids

The cooking is for adults only, because of the hot syrup and the powerful mixer. Keep children well out of the kitchen until the marshmallow is made. After that, there are plenty of fun jobs.

• Ages 3 and up: decorate labels and gift tags, and tie ribbon on jars (with help).

• Ages 4 and up: sift the dusting mix and toss the cut marshmallows in it. Small hands do this well, and it's wonderfully messy.

• Ages 5 and up: line the tin with baking paper and place the paper squares between the layers in the jar.

• Ages 6 and up: stamp out shapes with small oiled biscuit cutters, with an adult doing any knife work.

• Ages 8 and up: dip the cooled marshmallows in warm (not hot) melted chocolate, with supervision.

• Adults only: the syrup, the thermometer, the mixer and all the knife work.

My Favourite Finds

You'll find the things I love and recommend in my Amazon storefront for your country:

• Australia

• United States

• United Kingdom

• Canada

Let's Stay Connected

Come and say hello on Pinterest, Instagram and Facebook.

This post is part of my Edible Gifts From the Kitchen series. You can find loads more edible gift ideas and delicious Christmas recipes here.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This means if you click a link and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.

With love, Kim xx

Support

Connect

info@creatingcalmchaos.com

© 2026 Creating Calm Chaos. All rights reserved.